Landlord Tips

Rent reduction: what to do when a tenant asks for a lower rent

Apartment keys leaning on a model house, with banknotes, coins and charts behind

A good tenant is asking for a rent reduction? Don’t turn it down on reflex. First work out what an empty flat and a change of tenant would cost you, and compare that with the difference in rent. If you agree, put it in an addendum.

Ideally a fixed-term one, with an end date. In autumn 2026, with the student rental peak already over, tenants have more choice and can easily compare offers in the area. That’s why landlords are getting more of these messages. And note: this is not the same as a rent reduction for defects. There, the tenant has a legal claim. Here, they are asking for goodwill.

Should you lower the rent for a tenant who pays on time?

The numbers decide. Not whether the request sounds reasonable. A tenant who pays on time and causes no trouble has value too, and it’s worth putting a figure on it. Under Article 659 § 1 of the Civil Code, rent is an agreed term of the lease, so changing it requires the consent of both parties. In short: you are not obliged to accept the proposal.

Before you reply, check a few things:

  • whether the rent in the lease is still adequate, in other words how to set the rent in current conditions,
  • what condition the flat is in and whether anything needs fixing,
  • when the lease ends,
  • the tenant’s payment and repair request history.

And one test question. Is this person really going to move out, or just testing how far they can push?

Vacancy vs lower rent: how to calculate it

The rule is simple: a reduction pays off when the total of the differences over the period it applies comes to less than the cost of a vacancy and a change of tenant. Take two variables. R is the monthly difference in rent, M is the number of months the reduction lasts. The concession costs you R × M. And on the other side? Every month without a tenant, meaning the full lost rent plus the charges you cover out of your own pocket during that time.

The cost of changing tenants includes:

  • the building service charge and utilities paid during the gap,
  • time spent on the listing, answering enquiries and viewings,
  • the handover report and settling the deposit,
  • a possible refresh of the flat before the next let,
  • the risk that the next tenant turns out worse.

Oh, and taxes. If you pay the flat-rate tax on recorded revenue (ryczałt), lower rent also means lower taxable revenue. So in real terms you lose less than the gross difference alone suggests.

Rent reduction options that protect the landlord

A permanent, open-ended reduction is the weakest option for the landlord. It’s better to offer something limited in time or tied to something in return. Negotiating rent with a tenant doesn’t have to end in a bare “yes” or “no”. In practice, three solutions work best:

  1. Fixed-term rent reduction - a few months at a lower rate, then an end date and a return to the amount in the lease. It fits when the tenant has temporary difficulties or you want to ride out a slower season.
  2. Reduction for a longer lease - a lower rate in exchange for extending the tenancy, recorded as an addendum extending the lease. A good choice when you value peace of mind and the lease expires soon.
  3. Stepped reduction - a lower amount at the start, then a gradual return to the lease rate on agreed dates. It makes sense when the difference is noticeable for both sides.

Addendum: how to record a rent reduction

Draw up the addendum in the same form as the lease. Article 77 § 1 of the Civil Code requires an amendment to take the form that the law or the parties provided for concluding the contract, and a lease for more than a year should be made in writing (Article 660 of the Civil Code). In the document, state the parties and the lease number, the new amount, the date it applies from and, for a temporary reduction, the end date too.

State explicitly that the lease rate returns after the given date. Then going back to it is simply carrying out the addendum, not a new rent increase (if you have doubts about the wording, it’s best to check with a lawyer). If you ever want to raise the amount above the lease rate, a lawful rent increase has its own deadlines and form. The deposit? A reduction doesn’t reduce it, because under Article 6(3) of the Tenants’ Rights Protection Act the amount returned cannot be lower than the amount collected.

Using Tenanto? After signing the addendum, update the rent amount on the lease so the email reminder before the payment date goes out with the new rate. And add the addendum to the property’s documents.

How to say no without losing a good tenant

A good refusal is short, gives a reason and offers something in return. You don’t need to over-explain. It’s enough to say the rent matches the standard and location, and the costs of running the flat haven’t gone down. In return, you can guarantee a fixed amount for the next year, make a small improvement in the flat or offer a more flexible payment date.

Sample message: “Thank you for paying on time and looking after the flat. I can’t lower the rent, as it matches the standard of the flat and the costs of maintaining it haven’t gone down. What I can do is guarantee the current amount for another year and replace the bathroom tap you mentioned earlier.”

A rent reduction is a negotiating tool, not a defeat. What counts is the cost calculation, a clear addendum and a conversation that leaves the tenant feeling they were taken seriously.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to agree to a rent reduction when the tenant has found a cheaper offer?

No. Changing the rent requires the consent of both parties, and a cheaper listing nearby gives the tenant no claim. It’s different with defects in the flat that limit its fitness for use.

Can a rent reduction be agreed verbally or by email?

The form of the addendum should match the form of the lease. With a written lease you need a signed addendum. An email can at most serve as evidence of earlier arrangements.

What happens to the deposit after a rent reduction?

The deposit collected stays unchanged. When returned, its amount cannot be lower than what you received at the start of the tenancy, even if the rent has dropped in the meantime.